Construction of TiO2/WO3/TiO2 double heterojunction films for excellent electrochromic performance

Electrochromic devices are applied extensively to camouflages, smart windows, heat insulation layers, and automobile rearview mirrors, etc. The amorphous WO3 is a very attractive electrochromic material, whereas it suffers from degradation of optical modulation and reversibility on ion exchange owing to those deep trapped ions with irreversible reaction behavior. Herein, we designed and, by using magnetron sputtering, prepared a composite film with TiO2/WO3/TiO2 double heterojunctions, which is capable of eliminating the deep trapped ions by itself under ultraviolet light (UV) assistance. The electrochromic device based on this composite film, after being recovery by short-time UV irradiation, can maintain a high transmission modulation of 94.72% after 7000 cycles of the voltammetry measurement. This feature allows the device to maintain its initial electrochromic performance after prolonged use. Moreover, the double heterojunction structure can reduce colouring time and enormously improve the colouration efficiency (CE) of electrochromic devices. Experimental research shows that when the thickness of the bottom and upper TiO2 layer of the WO3 film was 145.5 nm and 97.0 nm, respectively, the CE of electrochromic devices reached a perfectly high value (479.3 cm2/C), being much higher than that of WO3 devices (69.5 cm2/C). Functions of the TiO2/WO3/TiO2 double heterojunction in electrochromic device were investigated by combining theoretical analysis and experiment validation, and these results provide a general framework for developing and designing superior electrochromic materials and devices.

The past decades have witnessed rapid development of electrochromic technology [1][2][3][4][5] .Extensive research efforts have been devoted to promoting the application of electrochromism in camouflages, smart windows, heat insulation layers, and automobile rearview mirrors those prevent reflected glare, etc. Particularly, electrochromic devices based on low-cost transition metal oxides (MoO 3 , Nb 2 O 5 , NiO, Cr 2 O 3 , WO 3 ) have attracted considerable attention [6][7][8][9][10] .Wherein amorphous WO 3 is the best known electrochromic material and one of the advance materials entering the smart window market 11,12 .The excellent electrochromic performance and cycle stability of WO 3 have been demonstrated in early research work.As early as 1975, Giglia reported amorphous WO 3 films in glycerine-H 2 SO 4 mixture had a long lifetime of 2 × 10 6 cycles at 40% transmission modulation 13 .Subsequently, a large amount of study has devoted to basic scientific research and experimental technology research of electrochromic WO 3 .Some representative research results have emerged.Typically, it has been demonstrated that electron injection in the surface states and/or accumulation of electrons in the conduction band can lead to significant color change caused by optical transitions, so increasing the specific surface area of WO 3 is expected to improve the electrochromic performance.As a typical example, WO 3 quantum dots in LiClO 4 electrolyte exhibited a fast switching speed (4.5 s and 4.0 s for colouring and bleaching), a high colouration efficiency (76.8 cm 2 /C) and a long cycle life (10,000 cycles with 10% optical contrast loss) 14 .Again, compared to the individual monometallic systems, the heteronuclear metal can regulate electronic environments and thus could optimize electrochromic activity and stability.TiO 2 has been proven to be a helpful partner of WO 3 for improving the electrochromic performance.The reversibility can be improved by adding Ti to WO 3 ; the lifetime of TiO 2 -doped WO 3 thin films can be several times longer than that of pure WO 3 15,16 .The recently reported WO 3 /TiO 2 electrochromic devices, being prepared by large-scale manufacture technology, displayed a very high transmission modulation over the wavelength range of 400 nm to 2000 nm under a bias voltage below 0.6 V 17 .
The electrochromic mechanism of transition metal oxides, including WO 3 , is based on the two indispensable activities, i.e. injection/output of electrons and Intercalation/deintercalation of small ions.With regard to electrochromic WO 3 , small ions (such as Li + , Na + , H + , Al 3+ and so on) insert into WO 3 matrices during the colouring process 18 .The kinetics of electrochromic colouration has been considered that small ions are localized near W 5+ color centers, probably by binding to oxygen coordination shells of W 5+ sites, which is also interpreted as ion trapping.Oppositely, during the bleaching process, small ions are pulled out of the local potential field around W 5+ sites by applying energy 19 .However, devices based on this electrochromic mechanism have a severe shortcoming, which is that the number of inserted charges is greater than the number of extracted charges during the colouring-bleaching process, and the difference between both usually increases with the number of cycles 17 .The ions that cannot be extracted during bleaching are bound in the electrochromic film.After multiple cycles of color changing, these bound ions seriously deteriorate electrochromic performance.The bound ion is considered as the product of irreversible reactions.
Theories of ion diffusion and relaxation have considered that the host structure contains two types of site: 'shallow' sites with low-energy barriers which allows the reversible and fast diffusion of ions throughout the film; 'deep' sites surrounded by high-energy barriers where ions become immobile once trapped [19][20][21] .These bound ions are likely to be the ions trapped in 'deep' sites.If these bound ions can escape from 'deep' sites, the electrochromic performance will also be restored.This point was supported by of Rui-Tao Wen's experimental research 19 .Wen et al. applied a higher electric potential on WO 3 films for 20 h, the electrochromic performance after degradation experiment can be restored to the initial state.
Herein we report a strategy to eliminate bound ions through the device itself in an environment with UV light, thereby disposing of the degradation in electrochromic performance caused by ions accumulation during repeated bleaching-colouring processes.This special function of the device is endowed by the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 double heterojunction.There are literatures report that the complex film of WO 3 /TiO 2 single heterojunction possesses an excellent electrochromic performance 22,23 .In addition, the use of the WO 3 /TiO 2 single heterojunction (usually a composite formed by nano-WO 3 and nano-TiO 2 ) as a photocatalytic material can significantly improve photocatalytic efficiency 24,25 .However, the proposed complex film of TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 double heterojunction has been rarely reported.The proposed TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 film, in which a WO 3 film was wrapped within TiO 2 films, reduces the corrosion of electrolyte on WO 3 .Furthermore, the transparent conductive film serving as a charge collecting electrode of the electrochromic device also avoids electrolyte erosion due to its coverage of TiO 2 film.Importantly, both heterojunctions forming in the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 structure can significantly optimize transmission modulation, colouration rate, and colouration efficiency of electrochromic devices.Moreover, we have demonstrated through theoretical analysis and experimental research that the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 structure can effectively utilize photo-generated electrons of TiO 2 to reduce the capture of ions at the aforementioned 'deep' sites.This feature allows the electrochromic device to maintain its initial performance after prolonged use.To our knowledge, this research work hasn't been reported yet.

Theoretical analysis
We conducted a theoretical analysis for the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 double heterojunction based on the energy band of solid-state physics.The Poisson's equation and the current continuity equations were used for simulating energy band of the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 double heterojunction (details is shown in Supporting Information).
The computation model was expressed in Fig. 1a, including the important physical parameters of each layer 22 .The difference between TiO 2 Fermi level (E f ) and WO 3 Fermi level is about 0.78 eV 26 and as well-known, a space charge region (SCR) is formed at the interface between both when they grew together.Based on Poisson's equation and the current continuity equation, we calculated the energy band diagrams of the thermal equilibrium system of TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 on F doped SnO 2 (F:SnO 2 ) substrate by mean of the finite element method, as shown in Fig. 1b.For TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 on F:SnO 2 , the bandgap of each layer and the relative position of their Fermi energy levels determine that TiO 2 layers constitutes potential barriers in the conduction band and potential wells in the valence band.Due to the TiO 2 work function (~ 5.81 eV) being smaller than the WO 3 work function (~ 6.59 eV), at the TiO 2 /WO 3 heterojunction 26 , electrons in TiO 2 conduction band transfer to WO 3 conduction band creating a positive charge region on the TiO 2 side at the interface and meanwhile holes in WO 3 valence band transfer to TiO 2 valence band creating a negative charge region on the WO 3 side.Similarly, at the junction of F:SnO 2 and TiO 2 , a positive charge region is formed on the F:SnO 2 side while a negative charge region on the TiO 2 side.The supposed charge distributions at heterojunctions are also expressed in Fig. 1b.
To compare with TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 on F:SnO 2 , we also calculated the energy band diagrams of WO 3 on F:SnO 2 , which is significantly different from that of TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 on F:SnO 2 .In the separated state, the Fermi level of F:SnO 2 (~ − 4.52 eV) is obviously higher than that of WO 3 (~ − 6.59 eV) due to that the electron density of F:SnO 2 is much larger than that of undoped WO 3 .Therefore, when the system of WO 3 on F:SnO 2 is in the thermal equilibrium state, the equivalence of Fermi energy levels of various parts results in a higher conduction band bottom of WO 3 compared to F:SnO 2 .Meanwhile, the as-formed built-in potential is mainly located on the undoped WO 3 side, but only near the interface on the F:SnO 2 side, as shown in the insert of Fig. 1c. Figure 1c also exhibits a corresponding charge distribution at the F:SnO 2 /WO 3 junction.
Comparing TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 on F:SnO 2 and WO 3 on F:SnO 2 , it is found that TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 on F:SnO 2 has the following advantages in electrochromic performance: (1) when no voltage is applied to the electrochromic electrode, the potential barriers of the conduction band generated by TiO 2 layers on both sides of WO 3 not only hinder self-bleaching owing to ion-escape from WO 3 , but also prevent self-colouring caused by fluctuations of environmental potential fields.Therefore the working state of the electrochromic device is more stable; (2) when a negative potential is applied to the electrochromic electrode for colouring, the TiO 2 /WO 3 junction connected to the F:SnO 2 substrate is in a positive bias, which reduces the potential barrier and thus is more conducive to injecting electrons into WO 3 .Conversely, the WO 3 /TiO 2 junction on the other side is in a reverse bias, which is beneficial for positive ion implantation into WO 3 .As a result, the colouration speed is improved; (3) the formation of a SCR can excite WO 3 colouring at the interface, which reduces the demand of injected charge quantity for the coloured state and thus helps to improve the colouration efficiency of electrochromic devices; (4) more intriguingly, the deeper traps of ions can be eliminated in the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 electrode.In an environment containing ultraviolet light, non-equilibrium carriers are generated in TiO 2 and WO 3 , and a part of electrons are enriched in the positive potential region of the SCR on the TiO 2 side, while a part of holes are enriched in the negative potential region of the SCR on the WO 3 side, causing the system to be non-equilibrium.The local potential field generated by these non-equilibrium carriers enriched in the SCR can promote the transfer of positive charges from WO 3 to TiO 2 .This means that the local potential field is helpful for those deeper trapped ions to be de-trapped and the good performance of electrochromic film keeps longer.All of these theoretical expected results have been verified by our experiments.

Experimental method Materials
The transparent conducting oxide, fluorine doped tin oxide (F: SnO 2 ) in our case, coated glass (FTO) having a sheet resistance of 14 Ω/□ used as substrates for the all experiments.Tungsten targets and titanium targets (99.99% purity, 60 mm diameter and 2 mm thickness) was purchased from Shenyang Baijujie Scientific Instrument Co. Ltd.The anhydrous chloroplatinic acid was from Sigma Aldrich.The electrolyte composed of 0.5 M LiI, 0.5 M 4-tert butylpyridine, and 0.3 M 1,2-dimethyl-3-propylimidazole iodine, as well as a low temperature thermoplastic foil of 60 μm thickness being used to seal the devices were supplied by Wuhan Jingge Solar Energy Technology Co. Ltd.

Preparation of electrochromic films
Using DC magnetron sputtering technology, the electrochromic films including WO 3 films or TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 composite films were successfully prepared under the optimized preparation condition which was described detailly in our previous article 17 Herein the important experimental processes are restated.TiO 2 , WO 3 , and TiO 2 layers were sequentially deposited on a cleaned FTO glass by DC magnetron sputtering pure metal targets (W and Ti).The effective area of all layers was 2.5 cm 2 .The distance between the target and www.nature.com/scientificreports/ the substrate was adjusted to be 18 cm.The working chamber was evacuated to 9 × 10 −4 Pa before sputtering.
During the deposition of the films, high purity argon (Ar, 99.99% purity) and high purity oxygen (O 2 , 99.99% purity) were used as the sputtering gas and the reaction gas, respectively.The preparation parameters are summarized in Table 1.
The flow rate ratio of O 2 to Ar gas is a key experimental parameter for preparing electrochromic films.When the oxygen ratio is too low, the resulting films have more oxygen vacancies, which affected the electrochromic performance.According to the evaluation of the electrochromic performance of electrochromic films, the gas flow rate ratio (O 2 /Ar) was selected as 1:4.The optimized sputtering power of WO 3 films was 100 W. At the same time, in order to tightly integrate TiO 2 film with the WO 3 film and reduce the unwanted stress, the sputtering power of TiO 2 was also set to 100 W.After fixing the parameters of gas flow rate and sputtering power, the thickness of the film depends on the sputtering deposition time.In the light of our experimental research, the WO 3 film obtained by depositing for 30 min exhibits an excellent electrochromic performance.Similarly, according to our experiment, the deposition time for the TiO 2 layer on FTO was set to 2 min or 3 min, while the deposition time of the other TiO 2 layer was set to 2 min.

Fabrication of electrochromic devices
The electrochromic devices was formed by assembling the as-deposited electrochromic film, a Platinum (Pt) thin film deposited on FTO glass, and the electrolyte into a sandwich type cell, which was sealed with a thermoplastic foil of 60 μm thickness.The structure of the electrochromic device is shown in Fig. S1a.The Pt thin film served as the counter electrode of these devices and was prepared by the spin-coating method which had been described in our previous paper 17 .The Pt-counter electrode and the electrochromic electrode overlapped face-to-face with each other and the areas used for connecting wires were reserved separately.Thermoplastic foils with a width of ~ 1 mm were paved on the edge of devices and heated at 130 °C for 3 min to fully seal electrochromic devices.The thermoplastic foil isolated the upper and lower electrodes as well as formed a cavity for storing electrolytes of the device.A small aperture had been punched by an electric drill at each corner of the counter electrode for injecting electrolyte.A drop of the Li + ion electrolyte was put in the aperture and it was introduced into the cell via vacuum backfilling.The device was placed in a small vacuum chamber to remove air.Exposing it again to ambient pressure causes the electrolyte to be driven into the device.Finally, apertures were sealed by cover glasses and the device assemblage was completed.Moreover, before experimental measurement analysis of electrochromic devices, we conducted several CV tests on the newly packaged devices to ensure stable performance.The names of electrochromic devices based on those different films are shown in Table 2.

Characterization
A field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM, Hitachi S-4800, Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) was used for study the surface morphology of the films, whose thickness was measured by using a step profiler (Bruker bektakxt).X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements were measured on a Bruker/D8 FOCUS X-ray diffractometer (Billerica, MA, USA) with a Cu Kα radiation source (wavelength at 1.5405 Å).The element analysis of electrochromic films was characterized by X-ray photoelectron spectrometer (Thermo Scientific K-Alpha).Optical properties were measured by the Ultraviolet-Visible-near infrared spectrophotometer (UV-Vis-NIR, Lambda950, Perkin).Electrochemical performances were tested by an electrochemical workstation (Zennium, Germany).The recovery test of electrochromic performance was carried out under an ultraviolet (UV) lamp with a wavelength of 365 nm and a power of 200 W.The UV lamp illuminated samples from above, with a distance of 5 mm between both.The light power irradiated on the surface of the tested sample was 20 W.

Results and discussion
The as-prepared TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 composite film was smooth and dense, which can be compared to the WO 3 film (Fig. 2), implying that the TiO 2 thin film formed stably and uniformly on the surface of the WO 3 film.The XRD pattern of WO 3 complex film revealed the as-deposited WO 3 film is amorphous (the insert in Fig. 2a).The  In addition, the cross-sectional view of the composite film is also shown in the insert of Fig. 2b, where the thickness of each layer was demarcated based on measurements using the Step profiler.The thickness of WO 3 film deposited for 30 min was measured to be 1047.7 nm, and thicknesses of TiO 2 films obtained by depositing for 2 min and 3 min were measured to be 97.0 nm and 145.5 nm, respectively.Figure 3 shows the transmittance spectra and bleaching-colouring kinetics measurements of these devices.After introducing a TiO 2 coating layer to WO 3 layer, ECD2 in the bleaching state still has high transmittance, and possesses an ultra-high transmission modulation in the visible light region.For readability, the transmission modulation at 580 nm is marked in Fig. 3a, which is 93.83% for ECD2, slightly higher than that of the WO 3 device (ECD1).Compared with both ECD1 and ECD2, the transmittance of the bleached ECD3 device clearly decreased.Meanwhile, its transmission modulation reached 99.55%, higher than ECD1 and ECD2, because of its extremely low transmittance in the coloured state.
Bleaching time and coloration time of these devices were revealed by bleaching-colouring kinetics measurements (Fig. 3b).As a reference level to calculate the colouring time or the bleaching time of the device, the highest  transmittance in the bleaching state as well as the lowest transmittance in the colouring state of the device were measured.The calculation range of colouring time is the time it takes to decrease from the highest transmittance to 90% of the lowest transmittance.Similarly, the calculation range of bleaching time is the time it takes to increase from the lowest transmittance to 90% of the highest transmittance.Obviously, the colouring time of ECD2 and ECD3 is shorter than that of ECD1, which is consistent with the aforementioned second advantage in the section of Theoretical analysis.However, the bleaching time of ECD3 device increased to 5.6 s, being longer than that of ECD1 as well as ECD2, while the bleaching time of ECD1 and ECD2 is equal.This is also caused by the double heterojunctions.As applying a positive voltage on electrochromic electrode to bleach the device, the TiO 2 /WO 3 heterojunction connected to the F:SnO 2 substrate is in reverse bias state, and the electron potential barrier increases, thereby increasing the hindrance force for electron extracting from WO 3 layer.On the contrary, the WO 3 /TiO 2 heterojunction on the other side is in a positive bias, and positive charges are easier for extracting from the WO 3 layer.Therefore, the contribution of both heterojunctions to the bleaching time is opposite.When their contributions cancel out each other, both of heterojunctions have almost no effect on the bleaching time, which is the reason why the colouring time of ECD1 and ECD2 is almost equal.The TiO 2 layer could not constitute a sufficiently long SCR when its thickness is smaller than the electron diffusion length (such as the 97 nm thickness).In this case, increasing TiO 2 thickness of the TiO 2 /WO 3 heterojunction adjacent to the F:SnO 2 substrate will increase the effectiveness of this heterojunction, leading to an increase in bleaching time.Therefore, ECD3 has a longer bleaching time.
On the other hand, the dynamic process of the Ionic charge has been regarded to be a main factor affecting the transmission modulation and bleaching-colouring speed of electrochromic devices.The characteristic was investigated by chronopotentiometry module of electrochemical workstation.A voltage square wave from 1 to − 1 V was exerted on the device to make it transform from bleaching to colouring, and both bias voltages held long enough so that Li + ions fully inserted into the electrochromic film and then completely extracted from it.The real-time detecting current of this process expresses quantities of the inserted/extracted Ionic charge as well as ion-transporting time.Figure 4 demonstrates the ion-extracting time and the extracted charge quantity for these different devices.As expected, the thicker the TiO 2 -cladding layer, the longer the Li + transporting time in electrochromic electrode.Interestingly, the Li + -ion charge of ECD3 device is much smaller compared to the other devices.In the colouring state, ECD3 device has extremely low transmissivity and fewer inserted Li + -ions, demonstrating it possesses an ultra-high colouration efficiency ( CE ), which is usually calculated according to the following formula: where T b and T c are transmissivities of the electrochromic device in the bleached and coloured states, respectively; the Q is the extracted charge quantity derived from the real-time detecting current curves, as shown in Fig. 4. CE s of these devices can be calculated according to Formula (1).Being convenient for analysis, the CE s of these devices at the wavelength of 580 nm are listed here, which are 69.5, 41.0, and 479.3 cm 2 /C for ECD1, ECD2 and ECD3, respectively.Obviously, the CE of ECD3 device is much high, almost ten times that of the other devices.This is consistent with the above third advantage obtained from theoretical analysis.During the SCR forming, electrons in TiO 2 conduction band transfer to WO 3 conduction band, resulting in a positive charge region on the TiO 2 side of the interface between both.According to the electrochromic theory of WO 3 , WO 3 colouring effect occurs while it obtains electrons and the accompanying positive charges.Therefore, the SCR can excite WO 3 colouring at the interface.It is thus clear that the SCR built by the thickened TiO 2 layer between F:SnO 2 and WO 3 compensates quantity of the inserted Li + ions, and greatly increases the colouration efficiency.
More attractively, the electrochromic performance of the device based on the TiO 2 -coated WO 3 film is restored or even improved after the numerous of cyclic voltammetry (CV) testing and ultraviolet (UV) irradiation.We conducted 1000 cycles of CV testing on ECD2 device and found that its dynamic performance did not decrease but increased.The performance improvement was more significant after 15 min of exposure to the UV lamp.For ECD1 device, however, both 1000 CV tests and ultraviolet light irradiation led to a decrease in the dynamic performance (Fig. 5).The experimental results are consistent with the above theoretical analysis, thereby proving that the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 double heterojunction is helpful for the deeper trapped ions to be de-trapped and improve the device performance.
In replicate experiments, this function of TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 double heterojunction is once again demonstrated.Figure 6 records the dynamic characteristics of bleaching and colouring of the electrochromic device at different stages of both CV measurement and UV irradiation.After 7000 CV measurements, the transmission modulation of the device based on the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 still reached 95.92%.Furthermore, the transmittance of the bleached device slightly increases after each exposure to UV light, meaning that UV irradiation is beneficial for the TiO 2 / WO 3 /TiO 2 device to recover to its initial state.

Conclusion
In conclusion, the advantages of electrochromic devices based on the TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 double heterojunction, including good operational stability, fast colouration rate, high colouration efficiency, and self-elimination of the performance degradation, were derived through theoretical analysis and have been confirmed by our experimental results.The electrochromic device can maintain the transmission modulation of 94.72% after 7000 cycles of the voltammetry measurement and possesses a super high CE of 479.3 cm 2 /C, being much higher than that of WO 3 devices (69.5 cm 2 /C).Ion trapping is a ubiquitous phenomenon, and therefore the technology that endows the device with ability to eliminate unfavourable trapped charges by itself, thereby maintaining ideal operating state for a long time, is a highly promising key technology.Although the relevance of this technique to practice devices remains to be demonstrated, it may open avenues towards superior smart windows and hence widen the scope for future buildings that are both energy efficient and comfortable for human occupation.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.(a) A computation model.The x-axis is a gauge of the thickness of each functional layer which was determined by experiments, and the y-axis is energy levels of F:SnO 2 , TiO 2 and WO 3 (vs the vacuum energy level of electron) when these materials are separated from each other; (b) the energy band as well as the charge distribution of TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 on F:SnO 2 substrate under thermal equilibrium, derived based on the principle of equal Fermi level (E f ) in a thermal equilibrium system; (c) the energy band and the charge distribution of WO 3 on F:SnO 2 substrate under thermal equilibrium.The Ec and Ev is bottom of conduction band and top of valence band, respectively.

Figure 2 .
Figure 2. (a) SEM micrograph of WO 3 film and its XRD pattern in the insert map; (b) SEM micrograph of TiO 2 /WO 3 /TiO 2 film attached with insert maps of its cross-sectional view and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy.

Figure 3 .
Figure 3. (a) Transmittance spectra of ECD1, ECD2 and ECD3, being the bleached state and the coloured state at the bias voltage of 1.0 V and − 1.0 V, respectively.ΔT(T b − T c ) stands for Transmission modulation, where T b and T c are the transmittance in the bleached and coloured states, respectively; (b) bleaching-colouring kinetics measurements of these devices at the wavelength of 580 nm under alternating voltaic cycles from − 1.0 V to 1.0 V.

Figure 4 .
Figure 4.The real-time detecting current curves of these electrochromic devices at an instant of the driving voltage square wave rising from − 1.0 V to 1.0 V.

Figure 5 .
Figure 5. Comparisons of bleaching-colouring kinetics between ECD1 and ECD2.The insert is an enlarged image of the transmittance curve in the bleached state circled by a dashed box.The black solid line, blue dashed line, and dotted red line are the test curves of both devices after 15 CV cycles, after 1000 CV cycles and after 1000 CV cycles, again being irradiated by ultraviolet (UV) light for 15 min, respectively.

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Comparisons of the bleaching-colouring kinetics characteristic of ECD2 after thousands CV measurements and repetitive ultraviolet irradiations.The bias voltage alternated from 1.0 V to − 1.0 V and each UV irradiation lasted for 15 min.The inserts are enlarged images of the transmittance curve in the bleached state circled by boxes.

Table 1 .
Summary of DC sputtering parameters.

Table 2 .
Names of electrochromic devices.The time in parentheses is the depositing time of the layer.